Sonny Bill Williams Slams Scott Robertson’s Tactics as Springboks Set the Standard

A Bitter Reflection: Sonny Bill Williams Criticizes All Blacks’ Coaching Strategy

In a candid and somewhat scathing assessment, double World Cup winner Sonny Bill Williams didn’t hold back in criticizing the recent coaching decisions of Scott Robertson, particularly in light of the All Blacks’ back-to-back losses against the Springboks. These losses, where New Zealand surrendered significant leads in both matches, have sparked intense scrutiny from fans and former players alike, with Williams leading the charge.

Back-to-Back Defeats: A Tale of Missed Opportunities for the All Blacks

The All Blacks found themselves in unfamiliar territory during their recent encounters with the Springboks. Leading 14-22 in Johannesburg and 3-9 in Cape Town, they ultimately fell short, losing 31-27 and 18-12, respectively. The second half of these games has been a particular point of contention, as New Zealand struggled to maintain their momentum, a recurring issue throughout the 2024 Rugby Championship.

Williams was quick to point out that this isn’t an isolated incident. Even in their dominant 42-10 win over Argentina, the All Blacks failed to score in the final quarter, a worrying trend that Williams attributes to a fundamental flaw in their game plan.

The 23-Man Game: Springboks Leading the Way, All Blacks Falling Behind

One of the most pointed critiques from Williams was his analysis of how the Springboks have mastered the concept of the 23-man game. “If we call a spade a spade, New Zealand isn’t the team from an aura perspective that it once was,” Williams remarked, noting how the Springboks have understood the importance of utilizing their entire squad, something he believes the All Blacks are failing to do.

Williams highlighted how the Springboks, under the guidance of Rassie Erasmus, have consistently rotated their squad and given significant minutes to their substitutes, building belief and cohesion across the team.

In contrast, Robertson’s reluctance to fully utilize his bench players, as seen in the second Test match, has not had the desired effect, leading to questions about the coaching approach.

Tyrel Lomax and the Question of Player Management

A specific example Williams pointed out was the management of prop Tyrel Lomax. While praising Lomax’s current form, Williams criticized the decision to keep him on the field for nearly 70 minutes in the high-pressure environment of South Africa. “The game is won through the middle,” Williams emphasized, suggesting that Lomax’s late-game fatigue was more a result of poor coaching decisions than the player’s own shortcomings.

Williams compared this situation to the strategic approach of the Springboks, who rarely keep their props on the field for such extended periods, instead relying on their depth to maintain intensity throughout the game. This contrast, Williams believes, is a key reason behind the All Blacks’ struggles.

The Impact on Player Confidence: A Divided Squad?

The former All Black also raised concerns about the impact of Robertson’s tactics on the morale of the squad, particularly those players who find themselves on the bench with little game time. “If I’m number 16 to 23 right now in the All Blacks and on the bench being used for 7 minutes, I’m sitting there thinking ‘Man, how am I part of the squad?’” Williams mused, pointing out how this could create doubt and division within the team.

This is in stark contrast to the Springboks, where even players who don’t start one week often find themselves playing crucial roles the next, fostering a sense of trust and belief throughout the squad. Williams’ comments suggest that Robertson’s current approach might be undermining the confidence of those players not regularly utilized.

Springboks’ Success: A Blueprint for Future All Blacks Strategies?

Williams’ critique doesn’t just stop at pointing out the flaws—he also seems to suggest a way forward.

The Springboks’ success, particularly their strategic use of the bench and their emphasis on the 23-man game, could serve as a blueprint for the All Blacks moving forward. If New Zealand is to reclaim its status as the dominant force in rugby, adapting and evolving in these key areas may be crucial.

What Do You Think? Should the All Blacks Revamp Their Game Plan?

Do you agree with Sonny Bill Williams’ assessment? Should the All Blacks take a page from the Springboks’ playbook and rethink their approach? Share your thoughts and join the conversation!